ALI Logo ALI
Search Books Updates
Home / Books / Kitāb al-Ghayba / Volume 1 / Invalidity of Kaisaniyya creed / Hadith 56
Hadith 56
Hadith #
56
Book
Kitāb al-Ghayba
Volume
1
Section
6
Part
Content
Chapter
Invalidity of Kaisaniyya creed
Source
Shaykh Muḥammad b. al-Ḥasan al-Ṭūsī
۞
This is the argument of a person who says that consensus cannot be discerned and as this question is not exclusive to our subject, there is no reason we should go into its details here. We know that the Ansar demanded caliphate and the Muhajireen turned them away and then Ansar submitted to the idea of the Muhajireen, according to the opponent. If someone should argue that Caliphate is possible for the Ansar, for a disagreement has occurred on this matter, and perchance there is someone in the peripheries of the earth who believes in this, whatever the opponent says in response to him, is our same answer here.
وهذا طعن من يقول إن الإجماع لا يمكن معرفته ولا التوصل إليه، والكلام في ذلك لا يختص هذه المسألة فلا وجه لايراده هنا. ثم إنا نعلم أن الأنصار طلبت الامرة ودفعهم المهاجرون عنها ثم رجعت الانصار إلى قول المهاجرين على قول المخالف، فلو أن قائلا قال:يجوز عقد الامامة لمن كان من الانصار لان الخلاف سبق فيه، ولعل في أطراف الارض من يقول به، فما كان يكون جوابهم فيه (فأي) شيء قالوه فهو جوابنا بعينه فلا نطول بذكره.
Tags Occultation

Similar narrations

  • Kitāb al-Ghayba #55 Objection: How can their extinction be known and why is it not possible that in faraway lands, such as islands and corners of the earth,...
  • Kitāb al-Ghayba #47 As for the third principle – that truth is exclusive to this Ummah – it is a common ground agreed upon by us and our opponents, even if we...
All narrations in Invalidity of Kaisaniyya creed Browse all books Search more hadith
Rewayaat

A project of the Academy for Learning Islam. Search, browse, and study Shi'i narrations in Arabic and English.

Explore
Updates Search Tips API Documentation
Contact
rewayaat.org@gmail.com GitHub Repository Academy of Islam
© 2026 Academy for Learning Islam (A.L.I.)
Content and translations remain the responsibility of their original sources.