Hadith 372
۞
The belief of those who say that Imam Hasan Askari (a.s) has not died and that he is alive; on the contrary he is the Mahdi, is invalid from the aspect that just as we know about the passing away of his ancestors, we are having information about his martyrdom as well, and the same arguments are applicable in this matter as well [mentioned previously]. In addition to this, those who had such belief are now extinct, whereas if they had been true, they would not have disappeared. The following traditional reports also prove the martyrdom of Imam Hasan Askari (a.s):
فأما القائلون بأن الحسن بن علي لم يمت وهو حي باق وهو المهدي فقولهم باطل بما علمنا موته كما علمنا موت من تقدم من آبائه. والطريقة واحدة والكلام عليهم واحد. هذا مع انقراض القائلين به واندراسهم،ولو كانوا محقين لما انقرضوا. ويدل أيضا على صحة وفاته:
Similar narrations
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #60 Waqifiya stop at the Imamate of Abul Hasan Musa (a.s) and say that he is the Mahdi. Their assertion is invalid, because his death was...
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #378 As for those who believe that time remains devoid of an Imam after Imam Hasan Askari (a.s), their belief is invalid, because we have proved...