Hadith 14
۞
The answer to this would be that, which we have explained in the context of necessity of Imamate; that his administration of affairs and fear of his reprimand are not availed by the duty-bound due to their own stance, because they forced him to go into hiding by threatening him and did not empower him to run the society. Therefore, this is an evil that they have caused themselves. This is similar to a case where someone says, “Religious obligations with respect to a person who does not have knowledge of the existence of Allah, the Exalted, is wrong, since he has not availed the knowledge that is a grace for him. Therefore, committing him to religious obligations is wrong.” In the same way our adversary would answer a question as such – that the infidel did that on his own, because Allah assigned ways to His cognition and gave him the capacity to attain belief, and if he did not respect that and did not attain faith, he did that on his own and this does not render his subjection to religious duties wrong.
قلنا: (قد)بينا في باب وجوب الامامة بحيث أشرنا إليه أن انبساط يده عليه السلام والخوف من تأديبه إنما فات المكلفين لما يرجع إليهم، لأنهم أحوجوه إلى الاستتار بأن أخافوه ولم يمكنوه فأتوا من قبل نفوسهم. وجرى ذلك مجرى أن يقول قائل: "من لم يحصل له معرفة الله تعالى في تكليفه وجه قبح" لأنه لم يحصل ما هو لطف له من المعرفة، فينبغي أن يقبح تكليفه.
Tags
Occultation
Similar narrations
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #13 Evil of belief in occultation of the Imam can be proved by stating that it removes hardships and hurdles from the duty-bound (Mukallaf),...
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #177 This suggestion is foul, because the reality is not as hinted as the Prophet (s) went into hiding in Sheb Abu Talib and in the cave in Mecca...
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #500 I heard Abi Abdullah (a.s) say: “There is occultation for the Qaim before his reappearance.” I asked: “Why is it so?” He replied: “He is...
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #17 We said this is disguising lunacy in lucidity, because he presupposes that we say that proof for existence of the Imam stands during...
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #20 We reply that the opponent has only complicated his argument, as logicians say, by turning around premises and referring them to one...
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #201 When he knows that he is obliged with religious duties and that his Imam is in occultation from him, he discerns that it is because of...
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #201 When he knows that he is obliged with religious duties and that his Imam is in occultation from him, he discerns that it is because of...
- Kitāb al-Ghayba #10 Second objection: Occultation violates the reasoning of necessity of Imamate in every age, because, if the fact that the presence of a...